NSPCA Discovers Yet More Cruelty

Published on 2/26/2015

NSPCA Discovers Yet More Cruelty

Please scroll down to view the response from the retailers…

A routine inspection of the GWK Abattoir and feedlot in De Aar in the Northern Cape by NSPCA Senior Inspector Grace Le Lange, uncovered yet more cruelty and farm animal welfare issues. This time the ill-treatment of lambs and sheep through extremely rough handling and bodily injuries caused by inept shearing.

Senior Inspector Grace de Lange of the NSPCA’s Farm Animal Protection Unit explained: – “I observed sheep being dragged by one of their hind legs. Some sheep were dragged upside down and parts of their bodies – including their heads – banged into the railings as they were pulled in this manner. I witnessed sheep being dragged by their ears and fleece, including being pulled over another sheep that was in a recumbent position. This particular sheep needed assistance to enable it to stand.”

Intervention by de Lange brought the process to a halt. One animal had up to 14 cuts on it. There are only two NSPCA societies for the entire Northern Cape area, one inspector is based in Upington and another in Kimberley. Due to these staffing constraints, NSPCA have to make special trips to these areas.

Criminal charges in terms of the Animals Protection Act will be laid against the Manager of the feedlot at the abattoir, the management of the BKB shearing team and 4 employees from that team. Of the approximately 2000 sheep shearers that are employed, 1700 are from Lesotho.

Sheepshearing_NSCPA
One sheep had up to 14 cuts. Accepted industry standards were contravened.

An examination of lambs and sheep that had been sheared revealed further welfare concerns. They had been placed in an enclosure and were being treated for injuries sustained during the shearing process.

“Fresh, bloody injuries. Cuts had been sustained during the process. Whether this was the result of negligence, poor training, lack of monitoring / supervision or sheer incompetence – the fact remains that animals have suffered unnecessarily and this is totally unacceptable. Visual evidence of lambs and sheep with bleeding wounds will be enclosed in the docket as supporting evidence.”

GWK Meat manages sheep abattoirs and feedlots in Groblershoop and De Aar.  The facilities are export approved and supply quality niche market products such as Food Lover’s Market Free Range Karoo Lamb, Fresh by Nature Lamb, Woolworths Free Range and Makro Natural Karoo Lamb exclusively to the respective chain stores.

GWK also manages the Beef abattoir in Jan Kempdorp and operates the Tri-Star feedlot near Hartswater as a custom-feeding facility.  The abattoir is export approved for Africa and the Middle-East.

NSPCAsheepAbbatoir

Food Lover’s Market

Another scandal that Food Lover’s Market had been named in was the donkey meat scandal where seven out of 11 products sampled from their stores contained undeclared meats or were incorrectly labelled. http://www.fruitandvegcity.co.za/contact/

Twitter:     Email: care@fnv.co.za

Food Lover’s Market Response

STATEMENT

27 February 2015 – We at Fruit & Veg City, owners of the Food Lover’s Market brand, have been made aware of the allegations of ill-treatment of lamb at the premises of GWK Abattoir, supplier of free range lamb to our group and other retailers. We are also aware and wholeheartedly support the NSCPA inspection and await the outcome of this inspection and its report. 

As a responsible retailer, we care about the condition of the livestock supplied to our butchery departments and only deal with suppliers that are ethical, and comply with the legal and regulatory requirements regarding the treatment of livestock, as set out by the Department of Agriculture.

GWK has confirmed to us that it outsources its shearing functions to a third party company, BKB Shearing Services. They are currently conducting their own investigation into the conduct of that company and have indicated that they will terminate their relationship with BKB Shearing Services should they find that industry standards were not met.

Food Lover’s Market views this in a very serious light and will ensure that all processes are followed to a satisfactory conclusion. 

​/ ENDS​

I asked Food Lover’s Market if they source their pork from crate free farms but have not received a response.

Woolworths

According to their own free range protocols registered through SAMIC, Woolworths states that they only sell Free Range Lamb and further say “…insistence that all animals destined for stores must be reared humanely and treated fairly in accordance with our code – abattoirs are regularly audited by a Woolworths technologist”.

You will also note an additional statement on this link of “an NSPCA-approved Animal Welfare Code of Practice;” NSPCA have requested that Woolworths remove this statement from their websites due to it’s inaccuracy. http://www.woolworths.co.za/store/fragments/help/help-index.jsp?content=contact

Twitter: 

Woolworths’ Response:

STATEMENT ON WOOLWORTHS LAMB

2 March 2015

The issues highlighted by the NSPCA contravenes Woolworth commitment to animal welfare.

We have found that this incident took place in January. The abattoir had subcontracted the shearing of sheep to a third party. The abattoir has since replaced the shearers with a more capable team.

We will take corrective action against such practices despite the abattoir being a third party supplier of Woolworths. We will be following animal welfare practices more closely at this abattoir as a result of this incident.

Contact Us

I asked Woolworths via twitter where they obtain their ‘free range lamb’ from. We have also asked how often they audit the abattoirs that they make use of since they claim “abattoirs are regularly audited by a Woolworths technologist”.

Makro

Is one of the many trading brands of Massmart. There is no public statement for animal welfare although Walmart owns 51% of Massmart. Walmart is among the worst big companies when it comes to making sure that the animals it sells are well treated, according to a 2013 report from the Business Benchmark on Farm Animal Welfare. http://www.massmart.co.za/contact-us/

Twitter: 

info@massmart.co.za

Fresh by Nature

Fresh by Nature is GWK’s own free-range natural lamb brand, they do not say on their website if they supply any retailers in South Africa. http://www.gwk.co.za/contact-us/

In 2014 the NSPCA submitted a list of non-compliant abattoirs in the country to the Department of Agriculture Forestry and Fisheries (DAFF), who is yet to respond.

Twitter: 

See more on the NSPCA here.

Sonia Mountford

Sonia Mountford lived as an expat in the Middle East for a number of years and enjoyed travelling and exposure to third and first world cultures. Her interest in food security began while visiting in Sri Lanka after floods and discovering the politics around Food Aid. As a co-founder of Grass Consumer Action and the only full time member, she spent four years researching the dysfunctional food system in South Africa, investigating, questioning and exposing misleading claims. Although her interests range from food politics to toxins in our food, including harmful ingredients in processed foods and Big Food influence; she soon came to realize that the most important part of the food journey begins on farms. For that reason she spends much of her time visiting farms, learning and talking about constraints and concerns in production methods with farmers. Passionate about nutritional food security she believes higher animal welfare farming practices are not only necessary for ethical reasons but also for human health. She is an ambassador for SOIL, BEES and healthy WATER. Mountford started EATegrity (eategrity.co.za) “Helping You Find Integrity in the Food Chain” in 2015. Her aim is create greater consumer awareness about the food chain and to encourage transparency in the South African food industry.

One thought on “NSPCA Discovers Yet More Cruelty

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *